Go Homedisinformation ®  
Welcome to Disinformation   |   July 06, 2003
     
item of the day
Abuse Your Illusions - the follow-up to Everything You Know Is Wrong & You Are Being Lied To is in the store and every bit as essential. The long-awaited Disinformation DVD is in too!
>>Go
personal of the day
U.S. Weighs Military Intervention in Liberia
>>Go
What The European Papers Say
>>Go
Violence Mars Nigerian Strikes
>>Go
Religion in the News: June 2003
>>Go
login
signup
email
chat
forum
store

activism
aliens
conspiracies
drugs
entertainment
environment
government
history
humanrights
media
mindcontrol
paranormal
people
philosophies
politics
science
sex
spirituality
technology

about
free newsletter
help


recovery nation: is aa threatening your freedom?
by Cletus Nelson (cletus@disinfo.net) - October 18, 2000
The nightmare begins with a malicious workplace rumor. A spiteful (and mendacious) co-worker fingers you as an excessive tippler leading management to give you a strict ultimatum: find another job or attend nightly meetings of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA).

With this brief administrative hearing, you abruptly enter the Kafkaesque world of 12-step coercion. Despite your lack of a drinking problem, economic necessity compels you to join the growing number of addicts and non-addicts alike being conscripted in record numbers to submit to AA's crypto-biblical "Big Book."

According Chaz Bufe and Stanton Peele's book Resisting 12-Step Coercion (See Sharp Press, 2000), every year an estimated 1,000,000 Americans are compelled to attend AA, Narcotics Anonymous (NA) or some form of 12-step treatment under threat of jail time, loss of employment, or other social sanctions. While you might consider yourself outside the purview of this powerful social force, think again.

"A young man working in a mail room tested positive for marijuana use in a random drug test. He was suspended from his job until he completed a drug treatment program," recounts Peele. The unfortunate youth who allegedly smoked the illicit herb "once a month" was in "constant conflict" with his counsellors, who demanded he admit he was "powerless" over his alleged addiction. This obvious attempt to pressure a recreational pot smoker into believing he was a remorseless drug fiend underscores the involuntary 12-stepper's plight.

Nevertheless, since its 1935 inception, the abstinence-based program which involves admitting your powerlessness over addiction and turning your life over to a "higher power" continues to enjoy unqualified public acclaim as a panacea for a variety of addictions. However, a growing number of outspoken critics are openly questioning the merits of 12-step orthodoxy.

In his seminal work Alcoholics Anonymous: Cult or Cure? (See Sharp Press, 1998), Chaz Bufe employs a wealth of scientific data to dispute both the efficacy of AA and its adherents espoused "disease model" of addiction. He specifically assails the organization's dogmatism, "chosen people" mentality, and the use of anti-intellectual "thought stopping language" to indoctrinate new members. These behaviors, Bufe notes, aren't "in the same league with vicious, destructive religious cults such as the Moonies and the People's Temple" but do exhibit "an alarmingly high number of similarities to such groups."

This assessment borderlines on the subversive when considering the vast influence wielded by AA in government circles. The federally-funded National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence (NCADD) which actively promotes 12-step treatment methods, has played a vital role in AA and NA's predominance in both Employee Assistance Programs (EAP's) and many lucrative public and private sector rehab facilities.

Yet to its detractors, this wealthy and influential organization constitutes an effective prohibition lobby propaganda voice. "Together, the war on drugs and its flip side, the 12-step addiction treatment industry, have threatened to transform America from a land of the free into a therapeutic state," declares Jack Trimpey, founder of Rational Recovery, a program which uses non 12-step methods to conquer addiction.

This is not to say there is anything inherently wrong with the many communal, store-front AA and NA chapters which provide a viable (and low cost) resource for those seeking chemical dependency liberation. However, when the state enters the picture, these seemingly benign 12-step programs quickly become re-education camps for drug war miscreants while providing an effective tool for social control.

Hopefully, the emergence of alternative treatment programs will offer greater choice to those seeking to end the vicious substance abuse cycle. We may then end our long-standing reliance on this singular treatment method that seeks to indoctrinate addicts and non-addicts alike.

 
 
more information  
 

The New Frontline In The Battle For Separation
To concerned atheists, implementing state-sponsored 12-step programs directly violates US constitutional statutes forbidding establishing a "state religion." The courts have agreed. This Web site provides a number of interesting essays and articles discussing this ongoing debate.

Alcoholics Anonymous: Of Course It's A Cult!
In this provocative screed, Jack Trimpey closely examines AA methodology and points out the many disturbing similarities between the 12-step method and those used by religious cults.

Piety Gets You Sobriety?
This acerbic (and humorous) essay by journalist Ron Larson provides a fascinating socio-historical examination of AA's rapid ascendancy in the dependency treatment field.

Cliff Walker's Recovery Watch
Cliff Walker is a strident opponent to 12-step methods. He provides a great deal of newsworthy and insightful materials regarding the sociopolitical ramifications to the widespread adoption of AA methodology. He frequently posts his acrimonious on-line altercations with fervent AA acolytes.

Alcoholics Anonymous
Nearly seven decades since the legendary "Bill W." and "Dr. Bob" teamed to form the legendary organization, AA is still going strong. The Web site includes publications, news, a directory of many chapters, and other resources. Extensively details AA's ongoing efforts to spread their universal message around the globe.

The Stanton Peele Addiction Web Site
Along with Chaz Bufe, Stanton Peele, PHd, JD has been one of AA's foremost critics. His engaging Web site discusses the clinical, legal, and social issues surrounding the 12-step leviathan.

See Sharp Press
Chaz Bufe's publishing imprimatur specializes in various anti-authoritarian publications and books that critique the 12-step movement. Highly recommended reading!

Rational Recovery
Rational Recovery is a growing organization devoted to non-12-step methods of recovery that take the "mystery out of addiction and recovery and, introduce some order into a field characterized by linguistic and theoretical chaos." RR dismisses the efficacy of group meetings, and encourages individual self-growth. They also wield a political action group who openly challenges the "AA cartel."

Moderation Management
Moderation Management advocates "controlled drinking therapy," which is rapidly gaining credibility in the addiction/dependency treatment field. They are stridently opposed to the notion that alcoholics are stricken with an incurable "disease" and believe problem drinkers can moderate their behavior through a series of proven techniques.

SMART Recovery
The members of Self Management and Recovery Training (SMART) believe addiction is merely a learned behavior that can eliminated by "unlearning" or dismissing "self-defeating" or "inaccurate thinking." Their teachings are entirely based on "scientific knowledge and evolve as scientific knowledge evolves."

Dick Sutphen's Battle For Your Mind
Dick Sutphen's thought-provoking brainwashing lecture explores the Pavlovian physiological roots of the AA conversion process, the widespread misuse of NeuroLinguistic Programming, and the dangers of "thought-stopping" techniques.

 
 


No Messages Posted Yet...


© 1997-2002 The Disinformation Company Ltd. All rights reserved.